Engelmeier & Umanah | A Professional Association

Minneapolis
612-455-7720

St. Cloud
320-230-0375

  • Home
  • Our Firm
    • Our Attorneys
    • Our Staff
    • Why Choose Us
  • Practice Areas
    • Business & Corporate Law
    • Compliance With Licensing Regulations
    • Early Childhood Education And School Law
    • Employment Law Representation
    • Estate Planning
    • Individual Specialty Claims
    • Investigations Complaints
  • Resources
    • Articles
    • Blog
    • E & U News
    • Video
    • What Our Clients Say
  • Contact
Engelmeier & Umanah | A Professional Association
612-455-7720
  • Home
  • Our Firm
    • Our Attorneys
    • Our Staff
    • Why Choose Us
  • Practice Areas
    • Business & Corporate Law
    • Compliance With Licensing Regulations
    • Early Childhood Education And School Law
    • Employment Law Representation
    • Estate Planning
    • Individual Specialty Claims
    • Investigations Complaints
  • Resources
    • Articles
    • Blog
    • E & U News
    • Video
    • What Our Clients Say
  • Contact

Over 30 Years Of Experience Navigating Employment, Estate Planning, Business And Education Law Issues

Google – An Opportunity Lost

On Behalf of Engelmeier & Umanah PA | Sep 27, 2017 | Information Technology

Google found itself in the middle of a situation regarding diversity and free speech this month. The basic facts are this-a tech employee, on a Google sponsored message board, wrote a ten page “manifesto” offering “biological” reasons for the abundance of males in Google’s tech area, potential solutions for remedying this disparity and challenging Google’s diversity activities as discriminatory, among other things. Somehow the document was leaked outside Google and, on the progressive side, the manifesto was met with outrage for its alleged biases and stereotypes. On the alt-right side, it was welcomed as a reasoned assault on rampant political correctness. I encourage readers to look at the manifesto yourself and make your own conclusions. Having done so, I don’t see the author as malicious or evil or a right wing zealot. Either way, Google found itself on the horns of a dilemma. On one hand it values the free expression of ideas without fear or shame. On the other, it values its commitment against bias and to promote diversity in the workplace. What it ended up doing was to fire the author. Now the author, James Damore, has become a pariah to the left, and a sacrifice to the altar of political correctness to the right. After reading the statement of the CEO, I thought of 1984 by George Orwell. Google says it “strongly ” supports the right of employees to express themselves, even with unpopular ideas, yet the message remains, if they do so, they violate the Code of Conduct. See statement of Google CEO here. https://www.blog.google/topics/diversity/note-employees-ceo-sundar-pichai/ Google has only itself to blame for the division that has exploded within its workforce, its users, and the internet because of this event. It has demonstrated it has a no tolerance policy regarding diversity-diversity of thought that is.

It appears that Google is in the middle of some sort of legal challenge to its lack of women in its workforce. Mr. Damore, whatever the merits of his manifesto, offered rationales for this disparity that have nothing to do with purposeful discrimination, exonerating his employer. By condemning Damore and his analysis, has not Google eliminated a number of arguments which it could have used to defend itself? As a defense lawyer, I scratch my head on that one. As a plaintiff lawyer, I rejoice!

Categories

  • Blog
  • Employment
  • False Claims Act
  • Firm News
  • Information Technology
  • Wages

Archives

Recent Posts

  • Giving Voice to Sex Harassment and Sexual Assault
  • Earned Sick and Safe Time in Minnesota – Update and Practical Guidance
  • Insight News
  • Congratulations to E&U’s Super Quartet – 2022 Super Lawyers®
  • The POWER 30: Shelia Engelmeier

RSS Feed

Subscribe To This Blog's Feed

How Can Our Team Help You?

Minneapolis

121 South Eighth Street
Suite 1300
Minneapolis, MN 55402

Minneapolis Office

Phone: 612-455-7720
Fax: 612-455-7740

St. Cloud

1521 Northway Drive Suite 115
St. Cloud, MN 56303

St. Cloud Office

Phone: 320-230-0375
Fax: 320-230-0408

  • Follow
  • Follow
  • Follow
Review Us
Pay Now

© 2025 Engelmeier & Umanah, P.A. • All Rights Reserved

Disclaimer | Site Map | Privacy Policy | Business Development Solutions by FindLaw